• Banana cream pie with whipped cream rosettes — a Pie Club sweet pick
  • Golden savory hand pies — a Pie Club savory pick
1 2

Criminal Baking & Catering Company

Pie Club Membership

Pie Club Membership

$40.00
$40.00
Sold out
Pie Type Selection
Type
Pickup Weekend of The Month

Billed monthly. Cancel anytime.

Your first order needs to be placed 5+ days before your pickup selection. If not, your order will be pushed to next month's pickup time.

From $40 a month. Pick your tier and your pickup weekend, and we’ll have your pies waiting at Pie & Pantry every month.

Choose your tier

  • Sweet Only — the month’s sweet pie — $40
  • Savory Only — the month’s savory pot pie — $50
  • Sweet & Savory — one of each, two pies — $90

See what’s coming on the Pie Club schedule, published through February 2027.

Choose your pickup weekend

Either the 2nd or 4th weekend of the month, at Pie & Pantry — 327 South A St, Santa Rosa, CA 95401, open Friday–Sunday 10am–4pm. Pickup only for now.

Member perks

  • 10% off all Pie & Pantry purchases and cooking classes
  • Monthly Pie Tasting Event
  • Not feeling this month’s pie? Trade it for anything in our market freezer at pickup — no questions asked.

Pre-sales open September 2026. First pickup is the last week of September, starting at our Pie Tasting Event on 9/25.

View full details