Sweet Pies

Golden-brown baked pie crust

Sizes & Pricing

  • 2 oz Petite Pies — $5 (great for catered events with dessert bars; minimum 12 per flavor per order)
  • 5" Minis — $12 (minimum 6 per flavor per order)
  • Full Size 9" — $48 (regular, gluten-free or vegan)

Shop full-size pies online: Fruit Pies · Specialty Sweet & Cream Pies

Fruit Pies

In a pastry crust. Please specify crumb or lattice top.

Apple · Apple Berry · Triple Berry · Blueberry · Blackberry · Black Raspberry · Cherry Berry · Cherry · Nectarine

Cream & Custard Pies with Whipped Cream

In a shortbread crust (or pastry crust upon request). Add dark chocolate ganache +$5. Available gluten-free.

Banana Cream · Caramel Custard · Coconut Cream · Coffee Cream · Chocolate Cream · Honey Lavender Chess · Key Lime w/ Graham Crust · Lemon Custard · Lemon Meringue · Peanut Butter Cream · Pecan · Pistachio · Pumpkin · Sweet Potato

To order, email criminalbaker@gmail.com or call 707-395-5395 with your order details, questions, and phone number. We require a minimum of 5 full days’ notice — the more notice the better to guarantee a spot on our schedule.