Savory Pies

Golden chicken pot pie with a flaky lattice crust

Sizes & Pricing

  • Hand Pies — $9.75 (minimum 12 per flavor)
  • Half Hand Pies — $5.50 (minimum 18 per flavor)
  • Minis — $14 (minimum 6 per flavor per order)
  • Full Size 9" — $54 (regular or gluten-free)

Shop full-size pot pies online: Savory Pot Pies

Vegetarian Flavors

Artichoke Spinach w/ Feta & Ricotta · Broccoli Potato w/ Cheddar · Chipotle Chili · Mushroom Stew · Mushroom, Chard & Swiss Cheese Bechamel (made with local Lion’s Mane mushrooms whenever possible) · Ratatouille Pot Pie · Veggie Curry · Veggie w/ Bechamel

Meaty Pies

Traditional Chicken Pot Pie · Seasonal Chicken Pot Pies · Chicken & Mushroom Pot Pie · Chicken Pesto & Mozzarella Pot Pie (no nuts in pesto) · Short Rib Pot Pie · Cottage Pie w/ Short Rib · Beef Stroganoff Pot Pie · Pulled Pork w/ Sweet Potato & Roasted Apples · Portobello w/ Spinach, Bacon & Bechamel · Red Curry Salmon Pot Pie

To order, email criminalbaker@gmail.com or call 707-395-5395 with your order details, questions, and phone number. We require a minimum of 5 full days’ notice — the more notice the better to guarantee a spot on our schedule.